Publication date: 17 Nov, 2026
Secure services and partner agencies in Scotland should work together more effectively to help young people understand and experience restrictive practices in a more consistent way, according to a new report.
Between 2025 and 2026, the Care Inspectorate and the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland worked collaboratively to review children and young people’s experiences of restrictive practices, including restraint, in secure care.
The report collates the findings of the joint visits across all four of Scotland’s secure services: Good Shepherd Centre Bishopton, Kibble Safe Centre, Rossie Secure Accommodation Services and St. Mary’s Kenmure.
Many of the young people inspectors and Commission officers met with said they felt safe in secure care settings and enjoyed trusting relationships. All services had a clear, child-centred vision, with organisational values that were trauma-informed and rights based. This reflected a positive ethos in terms of their understanding of the impact of restrictive practices on children and young people and their aim to minimise and reduce their use.
Inspectors and Commission officers also found many staff to be dedicated and knowledgeable, providing compassionate support to young people which made a positive difference to their time in secure care.
However, there were inconsistencies in practice and outcomes across the services, with not all young people benefitting from the most effective organisational approaches to minimising and reducing the use of restrictive practices. The report highlights significant opportunities for shared learning across the sector.
Inspectors and Commission officers found that children and young people being placed in secure care did not always understand the nature of restrictions they would experience before they arrived at a service. Further work was also needed on strategies to inform young people of the nature of daily life soon after their arrival. The initial anxieties and trauma of children and young people could be significantly reduced with more effective communication.
Young people who had experienced care and support in more than one service highlighted that the use of different practice models for restrictive practices was confusing and unsettling. As a result, the report notes there is potential merit to greater uniformity across a sector that is relatively small, specialist and has a nationally significant role.
Inspectors and Commission officers also noted there was not sufficiently consistent and evidenced assurance around physical wellbeing following all restraint incidents for all young people.
Whilst all secure services had access to Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS), there was inequitable provision of both dedicated psychological services and forensic CAMHS across the sector.
The report makes a number of recommendations, including that local authorities and partner agencies involved in the placing of young people into secure services should work collaboratively to ensure that every young person receives accessible information about the setting they are going to and about the restrictions that will be in place.
The Scottish Government should consider establishing a formal network with the singular purpose of disseminating innovative practice and learning between secure care services and policy stakeholders.
Assurance on the physical health of the young person must also be confirmed following every incident of restraint and be clearly documented and evidenced in care records.
Secure care services should action any individual improvements identified through the joint work related to the recording and quality assurance of incidents of restraint and seclusion. The broader quality assurance of restrictive practices should then identify themes for ongoing organisational development and learning, which contribute to achieving the promise’s ambition of children and young people not being restrained.
Julie Paterson, Chief Executive of the Mental Welfare Commission, said:
"We have written to the Scottish Government to advise that research into the impact of the implementation of the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act 2024 should be considered. The results should inform all stakeholders on the strategic direction and resources required to deliver the reduction of restrictive practices within this new legislative landscape."
Jackie Irvine, Chief Executive of the Care Inspectorate, said:
"The Care Inspectorate will continue to monitor restrictive practice in secure care services as part of their ongoing inspections. The Mental Welfare Commission and the Care Inspectorate will collaborate in 2027 to share progress made in relation to the recommendations detailed above."